| Platinum | Encore Threads & Treasures |
| Gold | Plato's Closet |
| Silver | RPM Thrift Store |
| Bronze | Kindness in The Village |
| Top Pick | Caught My Eye Thrift |
| Top Pick | Cedar Chest Thrift |
| Top Pick | Hopefully Yours Thrift |
| Top Pick | Posh Consignment Boutique |
| Top Pick | St. Vincent De Paul |
| Top Pick | Uptown Thrift |