| Platinum | Encore Threads & Treasures |
| Gold | Uptown Thrift |
| Silver | Cedar Chest Thrift |
| Bronze | St. Vincent De Paul |
| Top Pick | Hope Clothing |
| Top Pick | Pava Home and Garden Consignment |
| Top Pick | Recovery Room Shop |
| Top Pick | Redemption Prison Ministry |
| Top Pick | The Patch: Cambridge |
| Top Pick | Value Village |